How long does a clutch last? Signs it is wearing out

How long does a clutch last? Signs it is wearing out

A clutch commonly lasts anywhere from 40,000 to well over 100,000 miles, and how the car is driven matters far more than its age. A rising biting point, slipping under load and judder are the usual signs.

What wears, and why

A manual clutch is a friction disc squeezed between the engine's flywheel and a spring-loaded pressure plate. When the pedal is up, the disc is clamped and drive passes to the gearbox. Each time the pedal comes up and the disc slips while it grips, a little of its friction material is worn away, much as a brake pad wears.

Around it are a release bearing that presses on the pressure plate when you press the pedal, a hydraulic or cable system that operates it, and on most modern diesels and many petrols a dual-mass flywheel with springs inside it that absorbs vibration. Any of these can wear out before the disc does.

Why one clutch lasts twice as long as another

  • Town driving. Every pull-away slips the clutch. A car that does stop-start traffic and short trips gets through clutches far faster than one that cruises on motorways.
  • Hill starts and parking. Holding the car on the clutch on a slope, instead of the handbrake, is the quickest way to wear one out.
  • Resting a foot on the pedal. Even light pressure can part-disengage the clutch and wear the release bearing.
  • Towing and heavy loads. More torque through the clutch while it slips means more heat and more wear.
  • Extra engine power. A remapped engine can produce more torque than the original clutch was designed to hold.

The signs

  • Slipping. The revs rise but the car does not speed up to match, most noticeable in a high gear going uphill or overtaking.
  • A high biting point. The clutch only takes up drive near the top of the pedal's travel, where it used to bite lower down.
  • Judder pulling away. The car shakes as the clutch takes up, often worse in reverse.
  • A burning smell. A sharp smell like hot brakes after a hill start or heavy traffic.
  • Noise. A whirr or squeal that changes as the pedal is pressed points to the release bearing. A rattle at idle that goes when the pedal is pressed often points to the flywheel.
  • Difficult gear changes. Grinding into gear, or the car creeping when the pedal is fully down, means the clutch is not releasing fully.

Faults that look like a worn clutch

Not every clutch problem means a new clutch. A pedal that sinks to the floor, feels spongy, or will not come back up is usually the hydraulics: a leaking master cylinder or slave cylinder, or air in the fluid. On many cars the clutch shares its fluid reservoir with the brakes, so a low level there is worth looking at. A cable-operated clutch can feel heavy or bite higher because the cable has stretched or the self-adjuster has stuck, and both are much cheaper to fix than the clutch itself.

A diagnosis before any quote matters, because the first two hours of a clutch replacement go on taking the gearbox out, which is worth knowing before the fault turns out to be a cheap part.

What replacement involves and costs

On most front-wheel-drive cars the gearbox has to come out, and sometimes a subframe with it, so the job is usually a full day and on some cars two. The parts are sold as a kit of disc, pressure plate and release bearing, and a garage will normally fit the whole kit, because the labour to reach any one of them is the same.

Where the car has a dual-mass flywheel, replacing it with the clutch adds substantially to the bill, and four-wheel-drive and larger cars cost more again. Ask for a written quote that says which parts it covers. Whether the flywheel needs replacing depends on its condition when the gearbox is out, so ask for the quote both ways. Many garages also replace a concentric slave cylinder, which sits inside the bell housing, at the same time, since it is cheap and reaching it later means doing the whole job again.

Questions worth asking

Ask which brand of clutch kit will be fitted, whether the flywheel will be checked and what happens to the price if it needs replacing, whether the slave cylinder is included, and what warranty covers the parts and the labour. And ask to see the old disc, which shows how much friction material was left.

Making the next one last

Use the handbrake on slopes and in queues, take your foot off the pedal between gear changes, and pull away with no more revs than the car needs. Put it in neutral rather than holding the pedal down at long traffic lights. None of this costs anything, and on a car that does mostly town miles it can make a large difference to how long the clutch lasts.

Common questions

Is a slipping clutch safe to drive on?

For a short time, gently, it is not usually dangerous, but it gets worse rather than better, and a clutch that stops gripping leaves you stranded. It also makes overtaking unpredictable.

Do automatic cars have a clutch?

A traditional automatic uses a torque converter rather than a clutch you wear out. Dual-clutch automatics have two clutches that do wear, and their replacement is a specialist job.

Does the MOT check the clutch?

No. The condition of the clutch and gearbox is outside the test, so a car can pass with a clutch close to the end of its life.

Can I replace only the clutch disc?

It can be done, but the labour is the same as fitting the whole kit, so most garages advise the kit.

Where to go from here

Clutch replacement by town

Read next